3 people killed, dozens injured as train derails in southern Germany
3 people killed, dozens injured as train derails in southern Germany
Authorities say a landslide triggered by heavy rain likely caused a train to derail in southern Germany, killing two rail workers and a passenger.
Read the full article on CBS World
Truth Analysis
Analysis Summary:
The article contains a significant factual error regarding the number of fatalities. Multiple sources contradict the claim that only three people died, reporting the death toll as four. The article presents the information in a relatively neutral manner, but the factual inaccuracy lowers the overall score.
Detailed Analysis:
- Claim: 3 people killed in train derailment
- Verification Source #1: Reports at least four people killed.
- Verification Source #2: Reports at least four people dead.
- Verification Source #3: Reports at least four people were killed.
- Verification Source #4: Reports at least four people killed.
- Verification Source #5: Reports four people were killed.
- Assessment: Contradicted by multiple sources. The death toll was four, not three.
- Claim: Dozens injured in train derailment
- Verification Source #1: Reports dozens injured.
- Verification Source #2: Reports many more injured.
- Verification Source #3: Reports dozens of passengers were injured.
- Verification Source #4: Reports dozens of others injured.
- Verification Source #5: Reports 30 injured.
- Assessment: Supported by multiple sources.
- Claim: Landslide triggered by heavy rain likely caused the derailment
- Verification Source #0: The article states authorities say a landslide triggered by heavy rain likely caused the derailment. The other sources do not explicitly confirm or deny this cause.
- Assessment: Unverified, but presented as the likely cause according to authorities.
- Claim: The train derailed in southern Germany
- Verification Source #1: Confirms the derailment occurred near a Bavarian Alpine resort in southern Germany.
- Verification Source #2: Confirms the train accident was in the Alps in southern Germany.
- Verification Source #3: Confirms the train partly derailed near the Alpine resort in southern Germany.
- Verification Source #5: Confirms the train derailed in southern Germany.
- Assessment: Supported by multiple sources.
- Claim: Two rail workers and a passenger were killed
- Verification Source #0: The article states that two rail workers and a passenger were killed.
- Verification Source #1: Does not specify who the victims were.
- Verification Source #2: Does not specify who the victims were.
- Verification Source #3: Does not specify who the victims were.
- Verification Source #4: Does not specify who the victims were.
- Verification Source #5: Does not specify who the victims were.
- Assessment: Unverified. While the total death count is incorrect, the breakdown of who was killed is not confirmed or denied by the other sources.
Supporting Evidence/Contradictions:
- France24, NBC News, NY Times, Al Jazeera, and Reuters all report that four people were killed in the train derailment, contradicting the CBS World article's claim of three fatalities.
- Reuters specifies that 30 people were injured.