Coal Miners With Black Lung Say They Are ‘Cast Aside to Die’ Under Trump
Coal Miners With Black Lung Say They Are ‘Cast Aside to Die’ Under Trump
President Trump has been a cheerleader for coal miners. But these miners say his administration is failing to enforce limits on a lethal workplace hazard.
Read the full article on NY Times World
Truth Analysis
Analysis Summary:
The article presents a biased view, suggesting that President Trump's administration is failing coal miners with black lung. While sources confirm potential issues with safety nets and screenings, the article's strong negative framing and lack of comprehensive data on policy impacts contribute to a low factual accuracy score.
Detailed Analysis:
- Claim: President Trump has been a cheerleader for coal miners.
- Verification Source #3: CNN reports that coal miners backed Trump.
- Assessment: Supported by source 3.
- Claim: Miners say his administration is failing to enforce limits on a lethal workplace hazard.
- Verification Source #1: CBS News reports on West Virginia coal miners losing black lung screenings after Trump's administration slashes worker safety agency NIOSH.
- Verification Source #3: CNN reports that Trump dismantled their safety net.
- Assessment: Supported by sources 1 and 3, but the extent and direct causation are not fully established. The claim is framed negatively.
- Claim: Coal miners are being 'cast aside to die' under Trump.
- Verification Source #1: CBS News quotes a person saying, 'I'm angry that we are just being cast aside.'
- Assessment: Partially supported by source 1, which includes a quote using similar language. However, attributing this sentiment to all miners and directly linking it to Trump's policies requires further evidence. The phrase is emotionally charged.
Supporting Evidence/Contradictions:
- Source 1: 'I'm angry that we are just being cast aside,' Blackwood said. Her job was eliminated April 1, along with over…
- Source 3: Coal miners backed Trump. He's dismantled their safety net | CNN