Cassidy Got Pledges From RFK Jr. on Vaccines. They Haven’t Stuck.
Cassidy Got Pledges From RFK Jr. on Vaccines. They Haven’t Stuck.
Before casting a crucial vote for the health secretary, the top Senate Republican laid out several specific commitments he had secured, some of which appear to have been breached.
Read the full article on NY Times Politics
Truth Analysis
Analysis Summary:
The article's central claim that RFK Jr. breached commitments to Senator Cassidy regarding vaccines is supported by some sources but lacks specific details on the exact nature of those commitments. The article exhibits moderate bias by focusing on alleged breaches without providing RFK Jr.'s perspective or a full context of the agreements. Some claims are unverified, and the overall picture is somewhat slanted against RFK Jr.
Detailed Analysis:
- Claim: Cassidy secured specific commitments from RFK Jr. before voting for him.
- Verification Source #2: Confirms Senator Cassidy raised the issue of vaccines with RFK Jr.
- Verification Source #5: States that RFK Jr. made pledges to senators like Cassidy during his confirmation hearings.
- Assessment: Supported, but lacks specifics on the commitments themselves.
- Claim: Some of the commitments made by RFK Jr. appear to have been breached.
- Verification Source #5: States that RFK Jr.'s actions contradict pledges he made to senators like Cassidy during his confirmation hearings.
- Assessment: Supported by source 5, but the specific actions and pledges need further clarification.
- Claim: RFK Jr. has a long history of opposing widely accepted vaccines.
- Verification Source #1: Confirms RFK Jr.'s history of opposing widely accepted vaccines.
- Assessment: Supported.
- Claim: RFK Jr. said CDC employees were 'killing children'.
- Verification Source #3: Reports that RFK Jr. said CDC employees were 'killing children'.
- Assessment: Supported.
Supporting Evidence/Contradictions:
- Source 5: "All of these actions contradict pledges Kennedy made to senators like Cassidy during his confirmation hearings, when he..."
- Source 1: "Robert F. Kennedy Jr., despite his long history of opposing widely accepted vaccines, is a step closer to leading the nation's health agencies."