Fragments of 2003 Cable Detail Torture in a Secret C.I.A. Prison
Fragments of 2003 Cable Detail Torture in a Secret C.I.A. Prison
An interrogator covertly used a power drill and handgun to menace a prisoner, without permission from the agency’s headquarters.
Read the full article on NY Times Politics
Truth Analysis
Analysis Summary:
The article presents a serious allegation of torture within a CIA black site. While the existence of CIA black sites and instances of torture are documented, the specific claim about the power drill and handgun lacks direct verification from the provided sources. The article exhibits a moderate bias by focusing on alleged abuses without providing counter-arguments or alternative perspectives.
Detailed Analysis:
- Claim: An interrogator covertly used a power drill and handgun to menace a prisoner, without permission from the agency’s headquarters.
- Verification Source #3: Source 3 discusses the history of the CIA's Detention and Interrogation Program but does not specifically mention the power drill and handgun incident.
- Verification Source #4: Source 4 mentions a cable from CIA HQ authorizing the use of certain techniques but does not confirm or deny the specific incident with the power drill and handgun.
- Verification Source #5: Source 5 mentions the existence of secret detention sites but does not corroborate the specific claim about the power drill and handgun.
- Assessment: Unverified. While the existence of CIA black sites and documented instances of torture are acknowledged by multiple sources, the specific claim about the power drill and handgun is not directly supported by the provided sources.
Supporting Evidence/Contradictions:
- Source 3: 'The Study describes the history of the CIA's Detention and Interrogation Program from its inception to its termination...'
- Source 4: 'On 24 April 2003, a cable from CIA HQ to Detention Site Cobalt authorized the use against ...'
- Source 5: 'Both CIA records and prisoner testimony make clear that there was an evolving network of secret detention sites in Afghanistan...'