Israel "disregards the need to protect civilians" in war, Doctors Without Borders chief says
Israel "disregards the need to protect civilians" in war, Doctors Without Borders chief says
Avril Benoit, Doctors Without Borders executive director, and Janti Soeripto, Save the Children president, join “Face the Nation” to discuss the war between Israel and Hamas. “What we have seen time and again for the last six months, is that Israel is conducting this war in a way that completely disregards the need to protect civilians at all costs,” Benoit said.
Read the full article on CBS World
Truth Analysis
Analysis Summary:
The article's accuracy is mixed. The core claim that Doctors Without Borders believes Israel disregards civilian protection is verifiable, but the article provides limited context and relies heavily on a single statement. The provided sources confirm the conflict's impact on civilians and aid workers, but don't directly address the specific claim of disregard for civilian protection. This suggests a moderate bias through selective reporting.
Detailed Analysis:
- Claim: "Israel is conducting this war in a way that completely disregards the need to protect civilians at all costs," Benoit said.
- Verification Source #1: Mentions Israel's claim that Hamas operates within civilian infrastructure, using them as shields. This indirectly relates to the claim but doesn't directly support or contradict it.
- Verification Source #2: Reports on an Israeli strike on a humanitarian zone, which could be interpreted as supporting the claim, but Israel stated they were targeting a weapons launcher.
- Verification Source #4: Reports on the death of a Doctors Without Borders staff member due to an Israeli strike, which lends some credence to the claim of disregard for civilian protection.
- Verification Source #5: Reports on Israeli strikes killing aid workers and civilians.
- Verification Source #3: Reports on Doctors Without Borders closing its last facility in north Gaza.
- *Analysis:* The statement is attributed to the executive director of Doctors Without Borders, making it a factual representation of her opinion. However, the article presents this statement without significant context or counter-arguments. The provided sources confirm the occurrence of events that could be interpreted as a disregard for civilian protection, but also include Israeli justifications or explanations for some of these events.
Supporting Evidence/Contradictions:
- Supporting Evidence:
- Verification Source #2: "Israel Strikes Humanitarian Zone in Gaza" indicates that Israeli military actions have resulted in harm to civilians in areas designated for their protection.
- Verification Source #4: "An Israeli strike kills a Doctors Without Borders staff member" directly supports the idea that civilian protection is not being prioritized.
- Verification Source #5: "Israeli Strikes on Northern Gaza Kill at Least 20, Aid Workers Say" provides further evidence of civilian casualties resulting from Israeli strikes.
- Contradictions/Lack of Coverage:
- Verification Source #1: "Palestinians Flee as Israeli Forces Raid a Major Hospital in Gaza" mentions Israel's claim that Hamas uses civilian infrastructure as shields, which presents a counter-narrative to the claim of complete disregard for civilian protection. This source does not directly contradict the claim but provides context that the article omits.
- The article lacks a direct response from the Israeli government regarding the specific accusation made by Doctors Without Borders.
- The article does not provide statistics on civilian casualties compared to combatant casualties, which would provide a more comprehensive picture.