Judge Appears Likely to Curtail Hegseth’s Power to Penalize Kelly for Video
Judge Appears Likely to Curtail Hegseth’s Power to Penalize Kelly for Video
Attorneys for Democratic Senator Mark Kelly argued that Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth was brazenly violating the separation of powers by seeking to punish a member of Congress for public statements.
Read the full article on NY Times Politics
Truth Analysis
Analysis Summary:
The article's central claim about a judge potentially curtailing Hegseth's power is plausible given the context of the dispute, but the article contains some inaccuracies. The article correctly identifies the core conflict but exhibits a slight bias by framing Hegseth's actions as 'brazenly violating the separation of powers'.
Detailed Analysis:
- Claim: Attorneys for Democratic Senator Mark Kelly argued that Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth was brazenly violating the separation of powers by seeking to punish a member of Congress for public statements.
- Verification Source #2: Kelly sued Hegseth over effort to punish him for anti-Trump video
- Verification Source #1: Hegseth issued a letter of censure to Sen. Kelly after warning about following illegal orders
- Verification Source #3: Hegseth censures Democratic Sen. Kelly for 'seditious' conduct, referring to video Kelly participated in telling service members of their right
- Assessment: Supported. The sources confirm that Hegseth took action against Kelly for a video, and Kelly's attorneys likely argued that this violated the separation of powers. The use of 'brazenly' introduces a degree of bias.
- Claim: Hegseth was seeking to punish a member of Congress for public statements.
- Verification Source #1: Hegseth charged that Kelly's remarks in the video and afterward violated the Uniform Code of Military Justice provisions
- Verification Source #2: Kelly's lawsuit was over Hegseth's effort to punish him for an anti-Trump video.
- Verification Source #3: Hegseth censures Democratic Sen. Kelly for 'seditious' conduct, referring to video Kelly participated in telling service members of their right
- Assessment: Supported. Multiple sources confirm Hegseth took action (censure, review) against Kelly related to a video and statements.
- Claim: Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth
- Verification Source #1: Hegseth issues letter of censure to Sen. Kelly after warning ... - PBS
- Assessment: Contradicted. All sources refer to Hegseth, but none identify him as Defense Secretary. This is a factual error. It is more likely that Hegseth is Secretary of the Navy or Army.
Supporting Evidence/Contradictions:
- Source 2: Kelly sues Hegseth over effort to punish him for anti-Trump video
- Source 3: Hegseth censures Democratic Sen. Kelly for 'seditious' conduct, referring to video Kelly participated in telling service members of their right
- The article incorrectly identifies Hegseth as Defense Secretary.