Kavanaugh Acknowledges ‘Difficult Job’ of His Lower-Court Colleagues
Kavanaugh Acknowledges ‘Difficult Job’ of His Lower-Court Colleagues
Speaking at a judicial conference in Memphis, the justice expressed sympathy for the district-court judges whose rulings the Supreme Court has repeatedly paused.
Read the full article on NY Times Politics
Truth Analysis
Analysis Summary:
The article appears mostly accurate, reporting on Justice Kavanaugh's comments at a judicial conference. The bias is minimal, with a slight slant towards portraying Kavanaugh as understanding of lower court judges' challenges. The main claim is supported by external sources, although the extent of the Supreme Court repeatedly pausing lower court rulings is not explicitly verified in the provided sources.
Detailed Analysis:
- Claim: Kavanaugh acknowledged the 'difficult job' of his lower-court colleagues.
- Verification Source #1: Politico reports Kavanaugh saying, “The judges have difficult jobs — face a lot of pressure to get it ...”
- Verification Source #3: E&E News reports Kavanaugh saying, “The judges have difficult jobs — face a lot of ...
- Assessment: Supported by multiple sources.
- Claim: Kavanaugh expressed sympathy for district-court judges whose rulings the Supreme Court has repeatedly paused.
- Verification Source #1: Politico mentions lower-court judges expressing irritation at the high court.
- Verification Source #2: This source is a Supreme Court opinion and does not directly verify the claim but shows the Supreme Court overturning a lower court ruling.
- Verification Source #4: This source is a Supreme Court opinion and does not directly verify the claim but shows the Supreme Court making rulings that affect lower courts.
- Assessment: Partially supported. The sympathy aspect is inferred from the 'difficult job' acknowledgement. The 'repeatedly paused' aspect is plausible given the nature of the Supreme Court's role but not directly verified by the provided sources.
- Claim: Kavanaugh spoke at a judicial conference in Memphis.
- Assessment: Unverified by the provided sources, but plausible and likely accurate given the context of the other claims.
Supporting Evidence/Contradictions:
- Source 1: “The judges have difficult jobs — face a lot of pressure to get it ...”
- Source 3: “The judges have difficult jobs — face a lot of ...