Our Children’s Trust Suit Asks Montana Court to Block Some New Laws
Our Children’s Trust Suit Asks Montana Court to Block Some New Laws
The young plaintiffs, who won a major case over climate change policy in 2023, argue that legislators are illegally ignoring the effects of fossil fuels.
Read the full article on NY Times Science
Truth Analysis
Analysis Summary:
The article presents a lawsuit by Our Children's Trust against Montana, claiming new laws illegally ignore fossil fuel effects. While Our Children's Trust is confirmed as the organization behind such lawsuits, the specific claim about the laws passed in 2025 being in direct contradiction to court rulings is only supported by Our Children's Trust's website, introducing potential bias. The article lacks broader verification of the specific legal claims.
Detailed Analysis:
- Claim: The young plaintiffs, who won a major case over climate change policy in 2023, argue that legislators are illegally ignoring the effects of fossil fuels.
- Verification Source #1: States that in 2025, lawmakers passed laws that block the state from regulating, in direct contradiction to the Held rulings from the District Court and Supreme Court.
- Verification Source #2: Confirms Our Children's Trust spearheaded similar legal theories.
- Verification Source #3: Confirms Our Children's Trust is involved in climate rights lawsuits.
- Assessment: Partially supported. Our Children's Trust's involvement is confirmed, but the specific claim about the laws passed in 2025 is primarily supported by their own website, raising concerns about potential bias and requiring further independent verification.
Supporting Evidence/Contradictions:
- Source 1: "In direct contradiction to the Held rulings from the District Court and Supreme Court, lawmakers in 2025 passed laws that: Block the state from regulating..."
- Source 2: "Lawyers from Our Children's Trust spearheaded Juliana and developed the legal theories behind it."