Sasha DiGiulian becomes first woman to free-climb El Capitan's longest route
Sasha DiGiulian becomes first woman to free-climb El Capitan's longest route
Sasha DiGiulian free-climbed the roughly 3,000-foot sheer granite wall in Yosemite National Park over the course of 23 days.
Read the full article on CBS US
Truth Analysis
Analysis Summary:
The article's central claim about Sasha DiGiulian being the first woman to free-climb El Capitan's longest route is supported by some sources but complicated by others suggesting a different definition of 'first'. The article exhibits a moderate bias by focusing on DiGiulian's achievement without fully acknowledging other climbers' accomplishments and nuances in defining 'first' ascents.
Detailed Analysis:
- Claim: Sasha DiGiulian free-climbed the roughly 3,000-foot sheer granite wall in Yosemite National Park over the course of 23 days.
- Verification Source #1: Confirms Sasha DiGiulian became the first woman to free climb El Capitan's longest route.
- Verification Source #2: States that Sasha DiGiulian is attempting El Cap's longest free climb.
- Assessment: Mostly supported. The height and location are generally known facts about El Capitan. The claim about the route being the 'longest' and her being the 'first woman' requires careful consideration of the definition of 'free climb' and 'longest route' and is somewhat supported by source 1.
- Claim: Sasha DiGiulian became the first woman to free climb El Capitan's longest route.
- Verification Source #1: States that Sasha DiGiulian became the first woman to free climb El Capitan's longest route.
- Verification Source #2: Mentions Joslin as the first person to climb a certain route, which implies that DiGiulian might not be the absolute first on El Capitan.
- Verification Source #3: Claims someone else was the first woman to free-climb El Capitan under 24 hours, contradicting the claim that DiGiulian is the first.
- Verification Source #4: Mentions Lynn Hill as the first female climber to free climb The Nose of El Capitan, further complicating the claim of DiGiulian being the first.
- Assessment: Contradicted. While some sources support the claim, others suggest that other women have achieved 'firsts' on El Capitan, depending on the specific route or style of climbing. The claim is therefore not entirely accurate without further clarification.
Supporting Evidence/Contradictions:
- Source 1 supports the claim that Sasha DiGiulian is the first woman to free climb El Capitan's longest route.
- Source 3 contradicts the claim by stating someone else was the first woman to free-climb El Capitan under 24 hours.
- Source 4 mentions Lynn Hill as the first female climber to free climb The Nose of El Capitan, which suggests that DiGiulian is not the first woman to free climb El Capitan in general.