Trump Administration Violated Order on U.C.L.A. Grant Terminations, Judge Says
Trump Administration Violated Order on U.C.L.A. Grant Terminations, Judge Says
Judge Rita F. Lin ordered the National Science Foundation to restore grants awarded to the university, which she said had been suspended in defiance of the court.
Read the full article on NY Times Politics
Truth Analysis
Analysis Summary:
The article's central claim that the Trump administration violated a court order regarding UCLA grants is contested. While the NY Times and some sources claim a violation, others suggest the order was silent on suspensions, leading to ambiguity. The article exhibits moderate bias by framing the situation primarily from the perspective of a violation, without fully acknowledging the administration's counter-arguments.
Detailed Analysis:
- Claim: Judge Rita F. Lin ordered the National Science Foundation to restore grants awarded to the university, which she said had been suspended in defiance of the court.
- Verification Source #1: Reports that Lin's June order barred terminations but was silent on suspensions.
- Verification Source #2: Reports that Lin said the foundation violated the order by cutting off funding.
- Verification Source #3: UC researchers claim a judge's previous order barred the National Science Foundation from suspending UCLA's grants.
- Verification Source #4: Reports that a funding freeze on NSF grants at UCLA is “not in violation of the Preliminary Injunction provisions.”
- Verification Source #5: NSF terminated the initial batch of grants because they violated what the Trump administration feels are a waste of federal dollars.
- Assessment: Mixed. Some sources support the claim of a violation, while others suggest the order was silent on suspensions, creating ambiguity. Source 4 directly contradicts the claim.
Supporting Evidence/Contradictions:
- Source 4: funding freeze on NSF grants at UCLA is “not in violation of the Preliminary Injunction provisions.”
- Source 1: Lin's June order barred terminations but was silent on suspensions.