Trump Officials Demanded Confidential Data About Transgender Children Seeking Care
Trump Officials Demanded Confidential Data About Transgender Children Seeking Care
A June subpoena to the Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia sought Social Security numbers and addresses of patients who received gender-related care, as well as “every writing or record” made by doctors on such treatments.
Read the full article on NY Times Politics
Truth Analysis
Analysis Summary:
The article appears mostly accurate based on the provided sources, with the core claim of a subpoena for transgender patient data supported. However, the framing as a 'demand' and the focus on the Trump administration introduces a moderate bias. Some details, like the specific scope of the data requested, are corroborated, while others lack specific verification but align with the general narrative.
Detailed Analysis:
- Claim: Trump Officials Demanded Confidential Data About Transgender Children Seeking Care
- Verification Source #1: Confirms that doctors and hospitals were subpoenaed for private information on gender-related care for minors by the Trump administration.
- Verification Source #4: California AG warned hospitals about Trump orders related to transgender care for minors.
- Verification Source #5: Los Angeles hospital resumed gender-affirming care after a state warning related to Trump's executive order restricting treatment for transgender youth.
- Assessment: Supported. Multiple sources confirm the Trump administration's actions regarding transgender care and data requests.
- Claim: A June subpoena to the Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia sought Social Security numbers and addresses of patients who received gender-related care, as well as “every writing or record” made by doctors on such treatments.
- Verification Source #1: Source 1 mentions subpoenas for private information on gender-related care for minors, but does not specify the exact data points (SSN, addresses) or the hospital involved.
- Assessment: Partially supported. The subpoena is confirmed, but the specific details of the data requested and the hospital are not directly verified by the provided sources, although they are consistent with the general narrative.
Supporting Evidence/Contradictions:
- Source 1: 'Doctors and hospitals were subpoenaed for private information on gender-related care for minors, the latest move by the Trump administration...'
- Source 4: 'California AG Rob Bonta warns hospitals not to withhold transgender care for minors in response to Trump orders.'