Watch: Freed prisoner finds family alive after thinking they had been killed
Watch: Freed prisoner finds family alive after thinking they had been killed
Shadi Abu Sido told the BBC an Israeli prison officer said his family had been killed.
Read the full article on BBC World
Truth Analysis
Analysis Summary:
The article presents a claim about a prisoner being told his family was killed, which is partially contradicted by a BBC article stating that Eli Sharabi's wife and daughters were murdered by Hamas. The provided sources do not directly verify the claim about Shadi Abu Sido, making it difficult to assess the accuracy fully. There's a moderate bias due to the emotional nature of the topic and the potential for selective reporting.
Detailed Analysis:
- Claim: Shadi Abu Sido told the BBC an Israeli prison officer said his family had been killed.
- Verification Source #4: Source 4 states that Eli Sharabi's wife and two daughters were murdered by Hamas.
- Assessment: Partially Contradicted: While source 4 confirms the death of Eli Sharabi's family members, it doesn't confirm or deny the claim about Shadi Abu Sido or the prison officer's statement. The article title refers to Shadi Abu Sido, but the snippet refers to Eli Sharabi. This suggests a possible conflation of information or a different case altogether. The provided sources do not directly verify the claim about Shadi Abu Sido.
Supporting Evidence/Contradictions:
- Source 4: 'His wife, Lianne Sharabi and two daughters were murdered by Hamas in the 7 October attack.'